SF Planning Commission · Public Comment

34-36 PLEASANT STREET

58-6358 · 34-36 PLEASANT STREET

82comments
82in person
0emails
18hearings
20012002200320042005200620072008200920102011in person2001-01-11 — 1 comments, 0% in favour (click to read)2001-03-08 — 22 comments, 82% in favour (click to read)2001-04-12 — 2 comments, 100% in favour (click to read)2001-04-19 — 3 comments, 100% in favour (click to read)2005-07-21 — 1 comments, 0% in favour (click to read)2005-11-10 — 1 comments, 100% in favour (click to read)2008-01-10 — 1 comments, 100% in favour (click to read)2008-01-31 — 13 comments, 85% in favour (click to read)2008-07-17 — 7 comments, position not recorded (click to read)2011-01-20 — 25 comments, position not recorded (click to read)2011-05-19 — 6 comments, 17% in favour (click to read)email
dashed lines mark hearings · supportopposenot recorded · dot size = comments that day · click a dot to jump to the comment

Hearings

11 Jan 2001 — approveJan 200115 Feb 2001 — approve01 Mar 2001 — continuance08 Mar 2001 — approve12 Apr 2001 — approve with conditions19 Apr 2001 — approve26 Apr 2001 — approve14 Jun 2001 — approve21 Jul 2005 — approve with conditions10 Nov 2005 — approve with conditions10 Jan 2008 — continuance31 Jan 2008 — continuance06 Mar 2008 — continuance15 May 2008 — continuance17 Jul 2008 — approve with conditions20 Jan 2011 — approve with conditions17 Feb 2011 — no action recorded19 May 2011 — approve with conditionsMay 2011
approved  continued  denied / withdrawn  · 18 hearings · hover a marker for the date and outcome

Comments by hearing (82)

expand all · collapse all · comments with recorded text are listed first

2001-01-11 · 1 comments · 0 / 1
Roger Brandon · spoken · 2001-01-11 · oppose
- This project will propose a problem to the buses coming and going to the terminal. - The question is  how much office space do we really need? - There are a large number of office buildings, which are not being fully used.
2001-03-08 · 22 comments · 18 / 4
Bill Barnes · spoken · 2001-03-08 · oppose
The Supervisor in District 6 has been working on this open space issue. 185 Berry has a lot of open space yet this proposal is for indoor open space. The Park and Rec's priority is to improve parks in the City. This project is not going to provide open space.
Jeffrey Leivobitz · spoken · 2001-03-08 · oppose
Regarding public open space, 101 Second is a magnificent building in this City. It has a grand open space. Yet it's just a lobby. It is not an open space. The proposed construction will have a grand open space. It is an important issue to stop counting lobbies and start counting open spaces. He has worked for several contractors in the City.
Craig Allison · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Co-Owner of Plant Construction Company They have been in business for 54 years and are a local San Francisco business. He would like to talk about trustworthiness of the developer. His company stared working on the Pacific buildings with just a handshake. He has never had any problems with this developer.
Arnold Townsend · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
One of the things heard in San Francisco is market rate housing and affordable housing. Many people have just given up and low-income housing is not heard of anymore. Many people are leaving San Francisco and going to other parts of the bay area. 801 Market has agreed to give $1 million to the housing fund and would help out the Agape center. This would significantly change what people have to pay to get into this t… show more
Mike Casey · spoken · 2001-03-08 · oppose
President of Hotel and Restaurant Workers, Local 2 He would advise the community organizations to get the money up front. Four years ago, their union was in front of the Commission because of the Palomar Hotel. As a result of that the conditional use language which was ultimately adopted including language that said:  project sponsor agrees that the hotel operations will be subject to any city card check neutrality… show more
Fred Bianucci · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Cupertino Electric He has worked in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He has worked specifically with Pacific Resources in several of their projects. Many of the projects have brought tourist dollars to San Francisco.
Victor Esposto · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Cupertino Electric He has been a member of Local Union 6 for the past 15 years. He has had the privilege to work for Pacific 1 and 2. Pacific Resources has been very good to their employees.
Dave Holguin · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Local 22 – Carpenters Union He has been a member of this union for 23 years. Pacific Resources has been a very good company to work with and would like to speak on their behalf.
James Hom · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Local 22 - Carpenters Union He has been a member of the union for 21 years. He urges the Commission to approve this project. Not only is Pacific Resources union friendly but they are also a very good developer to work with since they are very friendly and work with the union.
Jerry Lowrey · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Chief Engineer of Pacific Place PCX He has been a local 39 Stationary Engineer member since 1986. He was born and raised in San Francisco. This project will be a very needed addition to the area to complete the renovation between Union Square and Yerba Buena. This would be the last piece to complete this project. Pacific Resources were kind enough to send him to energy classes. They have asked for his opinion on energy efficient products and systems.
Carmen Johnson · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Executive Director of the Agape Outreach Center This center is a community based, non-profit organization, which was organized specifically for preserving low and moderate-income housing. In discussion with the Redevelopment Agency and a private owner to sell a site on 3 rd Street, Agape is in negotiations to develop low income housing for ownership. The infusion of an additional $1 million from 801 Market and Pacif… show more
Jan Casey · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Art Advisor for Pacific Resources She has worked on several large projects in the City. They have gone to the community and have chosen various types of art to be displayed at this site. Pacific Resources has done a lot to enforce art in the community.
Steven Glick · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Dean of the Downtown Campus for City College of San Francisco He has worked in this area for over 7 years. This project will allow Pacific Resources to finish the construction of building 3 and improve the area considerably. This project will also help City College improve their downtown campus and bring the restaurant that is currently located in the basement up to the first floor and provide their students with a … show more
Peter Roger · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Superintendent of Plant Construction He supports Pacific Resources and this proposal. He is a third generation San Franciscan. They are absolutely committed that their project is the better one. His association with Pacific Resources has been nothing but positive. It is an attractive design and will continue to revitalize the fourth street corridor.
Anita Hill · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Executive Director of the Yerba Buena Alliance representing the Yerba Buena Gardens neighborhood. She is here to support this project and to endorse it. From the point of view of urban infill, everything is right about this project. One of the delights of the south of Market is the big blocks and the smaller alleys. These will be improved with this project. The Union Square Association, the Market Street Association… show more
Bayardo Chamorro · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Owner - Pribuss Engineers, Inc. (minority business) This project will provide jobs for the union labor force. He urges the commission to support this project to keep union construction labor active in the City.
Tom McCann · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Local 38 – Plumbers Union He supports the project because it's 100% union. It will create many union jobs. He urges the Commission to support this project.
Philip Garcia · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Division Manager of City Park – Teamsters Local 665 He recommends that the project be approved. As a parking operator he has seen the improvements of the 4 th and Market streets. Having reviewed the plans of this proposal he is quite impressed with the project. The seismic retrofitting of St. Patrick's church is great.
Sue Hestor · spoken · 2001-03-08 · oppose
San Franciscans for a Reasonable Growth and Local 2 The issues with this project are that the people who surround the project are against the development. Cole/Fox hardware will go out of business if this office development is approved. The neighbors of this site will be driven out of business or make it difficult for them to operate. This development will hurt the neighborhood.
Judith Baker · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
South of Market Child Care, Inc. The developer has agreed to fees of relocating the childcare to 8 th and Howard Streets. Read a letter from a parent in support of the development since they will receive assistance for their relocation.
Jeff Lance · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Manager of Pacific Resource PCX The project is in a difficult location. Creating more door entries/doorways would create a more open space look. $1 million of additional moneys for escrow fees. Their housing fees are higher than 185 Berry Street. The 1.5 million will go to the housing fund, to the traditional non-profit development for low-income housing. There will be no pre-leasing requirements.
Tim Tosta · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Attorney for Pacific Resources PCX The Pan family, owners and developers of the property, has owned this property since 1996. 555 Mission Street has received staff approval yet it's been asked to take some type of modification to taper its tower. At the full size it's about 100,000 square feet (sf) of additional bulk, at the reduced 499,000 sf, it's about 63,000 sf of additional bulk. There is room f… show more
2001-04-12 · 2 comments · 2 / 0
Patricia Vaughey · spoken · 2001-04-12 · support
This is some of the best architecture she's ever seen in San Francisco
Clark Manus · spoken · 2001-04-12 · support
Gave a general presentation of the project and addressed the issue of open space
2001-04-19 · 3 comments · 3 / 0
Timothy Tosta · spoken · 2001-04-19 · support
Steefel, Levitt and Weiss - He believes that the written materials are detailed and sufficient to achieve the support of the Commission. - He is available for questions.
David Zainer · spoken · 2001-04-19 · support
Plant Construction Company - They are a union based company. - The developer has mentioned that if this project is approved they will be able to construct it. - He would like to see this project go ahead and create more jobs for people.
Carmen Johnson · spoken · 2001-04-19 · support
- Founder and Executive Director of Agape Outreach Center. - They are excited that this developer has made a commitment to invest in a community-based organization and build low-income housing. - They are excited about the workshops and community meetings they held. - They are really excited about what they are doing. - This project will help many people to stop living on the street and be able … show more
2005-07-21 · 1 comments · 0 / 1
Jerrad Chan · spoken · 2005-07-21 · oppose
This is a matter of law, not a popularity contest. Asked the Commission to think very careful about their decision because it might have legal repricautions. Frederick Bullick , second Discretionary Review Requestor Removal of the setback would have a negative impact on the air and light in three rooms of my house. Roger Lott, third Discretionary Review Requestor Concerned about his privacy and asked the Commission t… show more
2005-11-10 · 1 comments · 1 / 0
James Lee · spoken · 2005-11-10 · support
traditionally a San Francisco building can be remodeled/reinforced by plywood. We don't necessarily have to tear down everything. I have a big family and I would like to provide them with housing.
2008-01-10 · 1 comments · 1 / 0
Lincoln Lue · spoken · 2008-01-10 · support
no text recorded
2008-01-31 · 13 comments · 11 / 2
Robert Leung · spoken · 2008-01-31 · support
We have different uses for the classrooms. As you are aware, originally in our project we labeled the classrooms genetically and we intend to use them for these purposes.
Barbara Louie · spoken · 2008-01-31 · support
Shared her experience of how the church has helped her, especially during a recent surgery.
Daniel Lam · spoken · 2008-01-31 · support
I speak in support of the project because space is needed for different purposes and groups at more convenient times. Help us to help the community.
Peter Ng · spoken · 2008-01-31 · support
Shared his experience of how the church has helped his family.
Mary Ma · spoken · 2008-01-31 · support
We are a community based church who wants to be a blessing to the community. [Shared her experience with neighbors and classes serving the neighborhood]
Shun Mi Lau · spoken · 2008-01-31 · support
We value church settings that teach Christian education. We are serving the community and our classes go in groups by age. We need the space.
Cindy Jeong · spoken · 2008-01-31 · support
The church is a place for people to find love and compassion especially for newcomers in the Sunset neighborhood.
Ann Truong · spoken · 2008-01-31 · support
Shared her experience of how the church has helped her and her children.
Andrew Fung · spoken · 2008-01-31 · support
I'm in support of the project and many neighbors and local businesses support it too. [Read a letter in support from a restaurant owner on Noriega Street.]
Jerry Ma · spoken · 2008-01-31 · support
Traffic and parking is a problem in the City but the church encourages using public transit. Its members shop and eat out, which helps the local businesses.
Sam Mirza · spoken · 2008-01-31 · oppose
This project is going to impact negatively the area with its existing traffic congestion and most of the congregation is not from the neighborhood. Ron Dudum There are concerns about traffic patterns and scales with regards to the residential area, and I am sure they can be mitigated.
Mauro Diehl · spoken · 2008-01-31 · oppose
There should be a study of the impacts that large buildings would have on our neighborhood.
Doug Cain · spoken · 2008-01-31 · support
I am here to answer any questions regarding the photo study submitted in connection with this matter.
2008-07-17 · 7 comments · no positions recorded
Richard Huff · spoken · 2008-07-17 · —
no text recorded
John O'Connor · spoken · 2008-07-17 · —
no text recorded
John Schlesinger · spoken · 2008-07-17 · —
no text recorded
Larry Paul · spoken · 2008-07-17 · —
no text recorded
Gary Chan · spoken · 2008-07-17 · —
no text recorded
Robert Leung · spoken · 2008-07-17 · —
no text recorded
Douglas Chan · spoken · 2008-07-17 · —
no text recorded
2011-01-20 · 25 comments · no positions recorded
John Nulty · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
Randy Shaw · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
David Addington · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
Chris Schulman · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
Dina Hilliard · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
Hani Kailen · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
Edward Evans · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
Glendon Hyde · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
David Elliott Lewis · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
Stepehn Berezin · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
Susan Baya · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
Mathew Zibilittt · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
Walter Paulson · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
Richard Price · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
Michael Nulty · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
Davy Jones · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
Saseen Daniel · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
Terry Bass · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
Shannon Brookland "Rhoads · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
Karim Rantisi · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
Ed Ivey · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
Illya Fee · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
Rodney Crawford · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
Regi Meadows · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
Joseph Brown · spoken · 2011-01-20 · —
no text recorded
2011-05-19 · 6 comments · 1 / 5
Elsa Dixon · spoken · 2011-05-19 · oppose
no text recorded
Alfonso Fostino · spoken · 2011-05-19 · support
no text recorded
Jennifer Solomon · spoken · 2011-05-19 · oppose
no text recorded
Ellen Bermingham · spoken · 2011-05-19 · oppose
no text recorded
Tim Culler · spoken · 2011-05-19 · oppose
no text recorded
Millie Lum · spoken · 2011-05-19 · oppose
no text recorded