SF Planning Commission · Public Comment

185 Berry Street

58-6309 · 185 Berry Street

40comments
40in person
0emails
14hearings
20002001in person2000-07-06 — 6 comments, 67% in favour (click to read)2000-09-07 — 6 comments, 67% in favour (click to read)2000-11-02 — 6 comments, 67% in favour (click to read)2000-12-14 — 2 comments, 100% in favour (click to read)2001-02-08 — 6 comments, 83% in favour (click to read)2001-03-08 — 14 comments, 100% in favour (click to read)email
dashed lines mark hearings · supportopposenot recorded · dot size = comments that day · click a dot to jump to the comment

Hearings

22 Jun 2000 — continuanceJun 200006 Jul 2000 — approve with conditions24 Aug 2000 — continuance07 Sep 2000 — approve05 Oct 2000 — continuance12 Oct 2000 — continuance19 Oct 2000 — continuance26 Oct 2000 — continuance02 Nov 2000 — approve with conditions14 Dec 2000 — approve25 Jan 2001 — continuance08 Feb 2001 — approve01 Mar 2001 — no action recorded08 Mar 2001 — approveMar 2001
approved  continued  denied / withdrawn  · 14 hearings · hover a marker for the date and outcome

Comments by hearing (40)

expand all · collapse all · comments with recorded text are listed first

2000-07-06 · 6 comments · 4 / 2
Tim Tosta · spoken · 2000-07-06 · support
Baker and McKenzie - Attorney for Project Sponsor - There are two owners: the undeveloped parcel is one ownership and 160 Harrison building is another related ownership. - The 160 Harrison Street building will store computer servers for Internet content. - There will be billions of dollars of commerce going through the computer servers installed in this building. - This building will provide security and reliable… show more
Michael Duncan · spoken · 2000-07-06 · support
Skidmore, Owens and Merril - Equipment needs to be put on the roof for height and airflow concerns. Air must go through where the equipment will be located. The equipment must be ventilated vertically and the air then allowed to flow out. - If this equipment was placed in the basement there would be a need to merge the first floor with the basement. There would also be a need to install ducts for air to ventilate ve… show more
Arnold Townsend · spoken · 2000-07-06 · support
- He has been working with the prospective tenant and the contractor. They have been very proactive and aggressive in terms of their first source hiring commitments. They will be working with training programs through community-based organizations and the City (e.g. people who are moving from welfare to work). - One of the opportunities that is about to be missed with all of these dot.com companies is that they are … show more
Debra Stein · spoken · 2000-07-06 · support
- They had an opportunity to speak to about 18 different organizations and mailed out about 1,000 mailers. Most everyone was very pleased with this project and are willing to work with them. A few concerns consisted of: lighting, security cameras, paint to reflect character of the neighborhood, etc. - They have not come across any opposition to this project.
Sue Hestor · spoken · 2000-07-06 · oppose
- She is not in agreement with the way staff has handled this project. This site needs to be re zoned for housing when it falls from public use. - Is this a business service use? If it is, then it has to pay transportation impact development fees. - If the site next door can hold a 600,000 sf building and 500,000 of it will be housing and this is a building of 125,000 sf then the ratio is 6 to 1 housing to commerci… show more
Anastasia Yovanopoulos · spoken · 2000-07-06 · oppose
- This use is more like an e-commerce thing. It is also a bit of science fiction. - Not very much business will go to the average citizen, therefore driving up the cost of housing. This will make the project next door not affordable and not compatible to the affordable housing needed in this city.
2000-09-07 · 6 comments · 4 / 2
Leo Cassidy · spoken · 2000-09-07 · support
- He has been working on this project for over 2 years. - It has been a long process to deal with the EIR.
Eric Quesada · spoken · 2000-09-07 · oppose
Mission Anti-Displacement Coalition - Although this project is out of his neighborhood, it is outrageous that not 1 of these units is labeled affordable. - He met with people from the Filipino community regarding evictions that they are facing. - He would like the Commission to turn this project down.
Sue Hestor · spoken · 2000-09-07 · oppose
- This is the largest live/work project ever. - There are many live/work developments that are being used as businesses. - The staff report does not talk about affordable housing. - It?s hypocritical that the Commission cries about housing which is affordable and this project does not have 1 unit which is labeled affordable.
Alice Barkley · spoken · 2000-09-07 · support
- There is a letter of opposition which states issues regarding parking, view blockage, etc. - All issues were answered in the EIR. (neutral) Perry Tomei - He owns property on Zoe Street. - He would like to receive the new plan for the project so he can review it. (neutral) Jeff Gotelli - He is a San Francisco resident and business owner. - He has major concerns of this development because the proposed buildin… show more
Jeffrey Leibovitz · spoken · 2000-09-07 · support
- Rincon Point/South Beach Advisory Committee - Their advisory committee took a unanimous vote on the access issue regarding the wharf. They believe that at some point they might entice the developer into opening up the gates or removing them completely.
David Cincotta · spoken · 2000-09-07 · support
representing project sponsor - This is the only site that is not in the Redevelopment zoning area. - Some of the aspects of the project are still being dealt with. - He is working with the Citizens Advisory Committee of Mission Bay.
2000-11-02 · 6 comments · 4 / 2
Steve Vettel · spoken · 2000-11-02 · support
Morrison and Forrester This project is entirely consistent and implements many policies of the general plan. In particular the Rincon Hill plan and the Rincon SpecialUse District. This is the largest project to come forward in the Rincon Hill area. There will be no displacements.
Clark Manus · spoken · 2000-11-02 · support
Heller-Manus This project will be good for the area. He gave a brief description of how the project will look. The project will provide views in the east-west direction and a commonpavilion in the middle.
Jeffrey Leibovitz · spoken · 2000-11-02 · support
He is a property owner near the port. He thinks this is a wonderful project in an area that is underutilized. It?s about time that housing catch up with the production of jobs in the City. One of the things that this neighborhood is really lacking is a grocery store.
Brad Paul · spoken · 2000-11-02 · support
He was here for another item but he just wanted to thank the developerof this project for providing this City what it really needs.
Edward Wiener · spoken · 2000-11-02 · oppose
He is a resident of the area. He has submitted written comments which state that the opposition to this project is not because it will block his view. The issue that he raised in his written comment is that the project iscompletely out of scale of the Rincon Hill area. The important thing here is the scale of the building and the design is very unattractive.
Anastasia Yovanopoulos · spoken · 2000-11-02 · oppose
Although she wants housing, her reservation if this 27-story building is earthquake safe and if there will be any more similar developments what are they going to fall on?
2000-12-14 · 2 comments · 2 / 0
Ken Iremonger · spoken · 2000-12-14 · support
- He would like to see the Shipley Street elevation.
Chris Maney · spoken · 2000-12-14 · support
- The concept is to develop a 78-unit residential unit with subterranean parking. - The building will have an open courtyard.
2001-02-08 · 6 comments · 5 / 1
Jacqueline Pitcher · spoken · 2001-02-08 · support
Homeowner in the neighborhood Empty lot has been there for sometime. It is a haven for drug dealers It is completely open for anybody to come and do anything Police Department has been notified Our neighborhood would much safer with a building on this lot This will upgrade the neighborhood
Tom Delante · spoken · 2001-02-08 · support
Recommend that the Commission approve the revised permit Construction has been going on since 1997, no work has been done since last August It is very unsightly right now Would like to see this project finalized Main concern is to have construction start again
Ian Warner · spoken · 2001-02-08 · support
Presented a letter from Lu Shamp in support of the project
Joe O'Donaghue · spoken · 2001-02-08 · support
Project Sponsor bought a set of approved plans, he didn't make up these plans, and was not aware of a private agreement. When private agreements are made they should have some method of recordation to validate them.
Christine Bender · spoken · 2001-02-08 · oppose
Drawings should be more specific Asked to withdrawn her DR in 1987, because Planning Department did not see any ambiguity Here today to asked and respect the time and money that was put in this project and honor the agreement Agreement between owner Submitted several documents: 1) Proposed elevations under the current height restriction; 2) What the building will look like with the… show more
Patrick Decent · spoken · 2001-02-08 · support
Mr. Warner attached and painted things to and on his property Mr. Warner has attach gutters to my property Mr. Warner is not being cooperative
2001-03-08 · 14 comments · 14 / 0
Bill Barnes · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Office of Supervisor Daly All of these projects are in District 6. Read a letter from Supervisor Chris Daly in support of the project.
Greg Cosko · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
President of Hathaway/Dinwiddie Construction Co. His company has a contract to construct this project. The financing is in place. His company has been in San Francisco for 75 years and he lives in San Francisco. Everyone is ready to begin construction pending the approval of the Commission. His company is 100% union and has been since unions were organized in San Francisco. This project has certainty of budget and ce… show more
Jeffrey Leibovitz · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Representing Mr. Rick Dickerson, President of South Beach Rincon Point Citizen's Advisory Committee He would like the Director of the department to work with Supervisor Daly so they can call for a hearing in front of the Land Use Committee. They have a resolution drafted to remove the gates. This would be the one and only opportunity to remove the gates. The BCDC permit allows them to have gates there restricti… show more
Jim Hornback · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Director of Business Development of AMPCO System Parking There is plenty of parking at this project. Parking is not a problem. He agrees with Ms. Hestor that this area needs to be rezoned.
David Snyder · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
President of the San Francisco Bicycle Coalition He has been working with this project for a long time. The project is a good one and is good for transportation. He agrees with Ms. Hestor that the area needs to be rezoned. The voters spoke on behalf of housing. It is worthwhile for the Commission to approve this project because it includes housing.
Richard Mulkerrins · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Able Maintenance Company His company has been established in San Francisco since 1926. He supports the expansion of China Basin. The additional space will create more jobs as well as more housing.
Terry Fancher · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Payne Weber Real Estate Their firm has had hundreds of employees in San Francisco for decades. They made an investment in China Basin recently. They are very pleased and very proud to be able to bring housing along with office at a wonderful location. They are substantial owners of various properties in the Bay Area. They hope to bring companies from Silicon Valley to the San Francisco area.
Kim Jackson · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Hotel and Restaurant Employees Union Local 2 She urges the Commission to place their award to 185 Berry Street instead of 801 Market Street. Housing is a priority of this commission. We need housing now. This project will meet the priority of this Commission and this City. This is the kind of development we need in this City.
Sue Hestor · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
She was the attorney working with the community organization of the ballpark. One of the things she noticed with the community surrounding the ballpark was that they had various issues: access to the waterfront and adding housing. She worked with housing developers and there were a lot of issues with housing along the bay. Have these issues been resolved? Yes. The one thing she does not agreement with in the staf… show more
Dan Howard · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Fisher Friedman Associates Working with City staff and neighbors such as Mission Housing, they moved to a mixed-use project by introducing 62 residential units including 6 affordable. This housing is over and above the in lieu-housing fee for the housing portion. It was a challenge to be able to come up with this design. The streetscape and the landscape will be softer and more pedestrian friendly because of under g… show more
Rodney Friedman · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Fisher Friedman Associates He has been in practice since 1956. The first mixed use project in North America was the Golden Gateway project and his company worked on it. He has received many awards for his project at the wharf. China Basin is almost 3 blocks long. He made several references to a model displayed at the hearing.
Tom McCarthy · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Co- President of McCarthy/Cook and Company China Basin is a 689,000 square foot (sf), two building office project located next to Pac Bell Park. The project consists of a 480,000 sf wharf side building and a 209,000 sf Berry Street side building. - The wharf side building was built in 1922 as a lumber warehouse and was converted to office space beginning in the 1970s. It features an 800 foot long, 33,000 sf award-w… show more
Pete Goldsmith · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
President of GCI He has been a tenant of China Basin for 10 years. He believes that China Basin has been at the front of renovating this area. He hopes that the Commission will approve the expansion of this project.
Jacque Keller · spoken · 2001-03-08 · support
Principal of Keller/Mitchell Landscape Architects She is a member of the design team but she is also a member of BCDC. They have been reviewing the Catellus project and open space. This project will add to the pedestrian liveliness of the area.