SF Planning Commission · Public Comment

Intent To Initiate Commission-Sponsored Interim Controls Related To The Mission Action Plan (Map) 2020

2015-000988

94comments
94in person
0emails
12hearings
2015201620172018201920202021202220232024in person2015-07-09 — 21 comments, 20% in favour (click to read)2015-07-23 — 4 comments, 100% in favour (click to read)2015-08-06 — 3 comments, 100% in favour (click to read)2015-09-24 — 3 comments, 100% in favour (click to read)2015-11-19 — 7 comments, 100% in favour (click to read)2016-01-14 — 10 comments, 100% in favour (click to read)2016-05-05 — 1 comments, 100% in favour (click to read)2016-06-23 — 4 comments, 100% in favour (click to read)2017-03-02 — 11 comments, 100% in favour (click to read)2024-12-05 — 30 comments, 93% in favour (click to read)email
dashed lines mark hearings · supportopposenot recorded · dot size = comments that day · click a dot to jump to the comment

Hearings

09 Jul 2015 — approveJul 201523 Jul 2015 — no action06 Aug 2015 — approve03 Sep 2015 — continuance24 Sep 2015 — continuance19 Nov 2015 — continuance14 Jan 2016 — approve with conditions05 May 2016 — no action23 Jun 2016 — no action02 Mar 2017 — approve26 Apr 2018 — continuance05 Dec 2024 — no action recordedDec 2024
approved  continued  denied / withdrawn  · 12 hearings · hover a marker for the date and outcome

Comments by hearing (94)

expand all · collapse all · comments with recorded text are listed first

2015-07-09 · 21 comments · 2 / 8
Tim Colen · spoken · 2015-07-09 · neutral
Production of affordable housing in the Mission + Eric Reid – 2050 Bryant Street support = Rob Poole – Affordability and evictions in the Mission = (M) Speaker – Blocked projects + Michelle Jones-Siegel – Auto repair (M) Speaker – Reject the controls, build more housing
Patricia Kerman · spoken · 2015-07-09 · —
It's about people, not buildings = Brett Gladstone – Grandfather date?
Peter Papadapoulos · spoken · 2015-07-09 · neutral
True moratorium = Sharon- AirBnB, short-term rentals, TIC, Ellis Act evictions, Emergency Task force = Sean Kiegran – Complex issue, PDR enforcement, taskforce = John O'Conner – Respect the pipeline projects, emergency taskforce
Steve Vettel · spoken · 2015-07-09 · —
Don't need interim controls
Rick Hall · spoken · 2015-07-09 · —
This isn't just the Mission
Roberto Hernandez · spoken · 2015-07-09 · —
Evictions, moratorium, housing pressure = Sue Hestor – Some good language, but misses the point = Christina Olague – Concerned about my community
John Elberling · spoken · 2015-07-09 · support
Make real controls or none at all = Eidelle Wilson – Good pot of gumbo – diversity of the City is leaving
Aaron Goodman · spoken · 2015-07-09 · —
Opposed
Carry White · spoken · 2015-07-09 · —
Sanity is needed, not unwarranted interruptions, controls would impact the whole City (F) Speaker – Interim controls do not serve housing crisis in the Mission
Adrian Simi · spoken · 2015-07-09 · —
This moratorium will keep poor people poor
Dairo Romero · spoken · 2015-07-09 · oppose
Mission not affordable
Jackie Barshack · spoken · 2015-07-09 · —
Masquerade for real controls needed
Diana Martinez · spoken · 2015-07-09 · oppose
Temporary halt on luxury housing in the Mission
Shigna Baktah · spoken · 2015-07-09 · oppose
Real crisis in the Mission. Controls do not correspont to the real
Tommy Abacoli-Mecca · spoken · 2015-07-09 · oppose
No luxury housing in the Mission, no interim controls
Sonja Transs · spoken · 2015-07-09 · oppose
Many can afford housing, don't interrupt market rate housing (M) Speaker – Vote against the controls
Edmund Larry-Juing · spoken · 2015-07-09 · —
Housing for humanity build = Andrew Gregg – Property owner concerns = Mary Eliza – Campos' legislation study
Mathew Sin-Young · spoken · 2015-07-09 · oppose
Vote against
Tom Swerk · spoken · 2015-07-09 · support
Make more housing
David Golden · spoken · 2015-07-09 · oppose
Supply problem in the Mission + Hiroshi Fukuda – Housing is being built, not for the people living here today
Scott Weaver · spoken · 2015-07-09 · oppose
Increasing rent, increasing evictions
2015-07-23 · 4 comments · 2 / 0
Georgia Schuttish · spoken · 2015-07-23 · neutral
Building on San Carlos, mergers, small building protection
Donald Dussett · spoken · 2015-07-23 · support
Housing crisis, displacement studies Zoe Amy – Controls don't go far enough, affordable housing Star Child – Housing shortage, November expiration, misguided moratorium
Steve Vettel · spoken · 2015-07-23 · neutral
2000 – 2070 Bryant project update
Lou Demintez · spoken · 2015-07-23 · support
Interim controls, grandfathered projects
2015-08-06 · 3 comments · 1 / 0
Susan Marsh · spoken · 2015-08-06 · neutral
(M) Speaker – Interim controls do not go far enough (M) Speaker – Affordability levels Naomi Tsung – Interim controls do not go far enough (M) Speaker – Displacement Patricia Kerman – Band aid on a broken leg
Lou Demataze · spoken · 2015-08-06 · support
Support for policy statement
David Carlos Salavery · spoken · 2015-08-06 · neutral
Timing for interim controls (M) Speaker – Support policy Laura Guzman – Support the policy statement Speaker – More housing John Schartz – (F) Speaker – Moratorium does not address the needs of the Mission (M) Speaker – Mission 2020 Plan
2015-09-24 · 3 comments · 1 / 0
Tony Mecca · spoken · 2015-09-24 · support
Appreciate the attention
Jon Schwark · spoken · 2015-09-24 · neutral
Ballot measue
Steve Vettel · spoken · 2015-09-24 · neutral
Concerns about density policy Sean Kiegran – Grandfathering provision (M) Speaker – We asked for something good for our community. This is not enough
2015-11-19 · 7 comments · 7 / 0
Georgia Schuttish · spoken · 2015-11-19 · support
In favor of continuance, consider expanding the District
Tommy Avecola-Mecca · spoken · 2015-11-19 · support
For staff to work on them more. Demo of rent-controlled units (M) Speaker – Support for continuance
Peter Papadapolous · spoken · 2015-11-19 · support
Support, strengthen the controls
Susan Syntad · spoken · 2015-11-19 · support
Support for continuance
Dairo Romero · spoken · 2015-11-19 · support
Support for continuance. More affordable housing
Sean Kiegran · spoken · 2015-11-19 · support
Outreach to the development community
Steve Vettel · spoken · 2015-11-19 · support
Packet contains the same controls proposal for 9/24
2016-01-14 · 10 comments · 6 / 0
Steve Vettel · spoken · 2016-01-14 · support
Good distinction between project size
Sue Hestor · spoken · 2016-01-14 · neutral
Look at the original plan description of the Mission
Sean Kiegran · spoken · 2016-01-14 · neutral
No winners, no loser, timing (M) Speaker – Not building housing for the neighborhood
Andy Blue · spoken · 2016-01-14 · support
Need more than 9 months
Jesus Gomez · spoken · 2016-01-14 · support
Domino effect, defacto demolition
Marie Sorenson · spoken · 2016-01-14 · support
The Mission is in crisis
Peter Papadopoulos · spoken · 2016-01-14 · support
Need for affordable housing Donald Dewsnup – Make it more difficult to build affordable housing in the Mission
Susan Cieutat · spoken · 2016-01-14 · neutral
Mission is being decimated
Lou Dematteis · spoken · 2016-01-14 · support
Support, extend controls to 18 months
Spike Khan · spoken · 2016-01-14 · neutral
25 unit cut-off, recommendations Rob Poole – Cannot support Scott Weaver – Impact of market rate development, under produced affordable housing in the Mission
2016-05-05 · 1 comments · 1 / 0
J. Scott Weaver · spoken · 2016-05-05 · support
Stabilizing the community
2016-06-23 · 4 comments · 3 / 0
Dairo Romero · spoken · 2016-06-23 · support
Community report
Peter Papadapolous · spoken · 2016-06-23 · support
Mission is ground zero for the crisis
Rick Hall · spoken · 2016-06-23 · support
Appreciation to Claudia Flores
Kate Hartley · spoken · 2016-06-23 · neutral
Response to questions
2017-03-02 · 11 comments · 4 / 0
Kevin Kitschner · spoken · 2017-03-02 · support
MOH statement regarding affordable housing
Sue Hestor · spoken · 2017-03-02 · support
Income levels shifts
Donald Dwsnup · spoken · 2017-03-02 · neutral
Continuance
Georgia Schuttish · spoken · 2017-03-02 · neutral
317 test ground
Corey Smith · spoken · 2017-03-02 · neutral
Importance of community
Dairo Romero · spoken · 2017-03-02 · support
Challenging, consensus, strong legislation, more resources
Chirale Bhukta · spoken · 2017-03-02 · neutral
Neocolonialism, gentrification
J.R. Eppler · spoken · 2017-03-02 · neutral
Potrero Hill and Dogpatch exclusion
Abbie Wertheim · spoken · 2017-03-02 · neutral
PDR Legislation, 16 th Street SUD overlay
Diana Martinez · spoken · 2017-03-02 · support
Community input Yoyo Chang, Aide to Supervisor Cohen – Removal of District 10
Lynn Woback · spoken · 2017-03-02 · neutral
Continuance request
2024-12-05 · 30 comments · 27 / 2
Ana Tolico · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Support
Omar Del Real · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Support Ani Rivera, Galeria de la Raza – Support
Rodrigo Lopez · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Prevent displacement in the neighborhood
Ruel Valderama · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Support
Kelly Hill · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Effective community-based planning
Teresa Almaguer · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Support and funded
Eric Arguello · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Continue initiative
Annette Garcia · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Equitable community development
Carolyn Fang · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Displacement
Larisa Pedroncelli · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Support
Martha Sanchez · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Importance of affordable housing
Martina Ayala · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Lack of proper funding, accountability
Antonio Martinez · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Support for small business and public schools
Crystal San Luna · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Safety of kids in the neighborhood
Tess Malek · spoken · 2024-12-05 · oppose
Impacts to residents
Aristos Kemiji · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Support to local small businesses, neighborhood programs
Alicia Bustos Sandoval · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Prevent displacements
Lizette Parilla · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Small business owner, safety concerns
Jenny Aguirre · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Small business owner, concerns on safety, street cleanliness, lack of parking, graffiti, homelessness
Jose Luis Pabon · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Cannot afford to live in the Mission
Roberto Alfaro · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Vision of the community
Craig Weber · spoken · 2024-12-05 · oppose
Missing a lot of information, flaws in the report
Mary Jean Robertson · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Responsibility to the land, cultural events
Mary Travis Allen · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Commitment
Jessica Rubio · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Support from businesses
Georgia Schuttish · spoken · 2024-12-05 · neutral
Housing = Income Inequality Issues? 25th and Alabama Streets before/after. Approved as Alteration prior to Section 317 and Demo Calcs. Became illegal AirBnB. Later high-end rental. How would Citywide Survey staff analyze today? A-rated? York Street before/after. Alteration, after Section 317 Demo Calcs approved. Completed 2018. Did create a second unit, both equal in size sold almost $2.5 million each. Appears to hav… show more
Lucia Obregon · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
MAP presentation
Susana Rojas · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Equity
Natalie Ortiz · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Events and activities
Paloma Tracy · spoken · 2024-12-05 · support
Equity initiative