2002-06-27 · 29 comments · 22 / 7
Sue Hestor · spoken · 2002-06-27 · oppose
Appellant - The zoning context for this site is not adequately explained in the Negative Declaration.
- There should be an analysis in the negative declaration of what is the difference between an industrial area and a residential area and the dramatic change that has occurred in the Mission District.
- This area has been eaten alive by high-end housing.
- She would like to have context information, as well, on how t… Appellant - The zoning context for this site is not adequately explained in the Negative Declaration.
- There should be an analysis in the negative declaration of what is the difference between an industrial area and a residential area and the dramatic change that has occurred in the Mission District.
- This area has been eaten alive by high-end housing.
- She would like to have context information, as well, on how this area has changed dramatically from light industrial to office and high-end housing.show more Sue Hestor · spoken · 2002-06-27 · oppose
- One bedroom units have one to two people in them.
- Some design issues need to be worked out before this project is approved.
MOTION 1: Approve, but require statt to continue to review and ultimately approve the design. The motion did not recreive a second.
Don Whorton · spoken · 2002-06-27 · oppose
- He is surprised at the many things that he has been accused of.
- He urges the Commission to deny this project.
Luis Granados · spoken · 2002-06-27 · oppose
- If this project is approved it will be directly in contradiction to existing policies for protecting industrial space in the NIMIZ.
- The property owners have been good business owners and have hired neighborhood residents to work there yet the neighborhood will not benefit by this project.
- Sixty percent of the people in this neighborhood will not be able to afford the units.
Al Lopez · spoken · 2002-06-27 · oppose
Mission Neighbors - He is not opposing housing. He is opposing the bulk and size of the building.
Kyle Fiore · spoken · 2002-06-27 · oppose
Mission Neighborhood Center, SPUR and MAC - There have been a number of loft units built in this area with no affordable housing attached to it. There is now zoning which asks for it and it is not taking place.
Judy West · spoken · 2002-06-27 · support
- She lives in the neighborhood.
- She is appalled that MEDA and Ms. Hestor are against this project.
- This project is what the City has been asking for.
Leo Cassidy · spoken · 2002-06-27 · support
Construction - He hopes that the Commission will approve this project.
Joe O'Donaghue · spoken · 2002-06-27 · support
- Most of the arguments are that the Commission should wait to make a decision on this project until community planning is complete.
- The other argument is that there should be something else built here.
- The Commission should approve the project.
Fabrizio Sttepani · spoken · 2002-06-27 · support
- He knows this site well and this project will improve the area.
- This project is good because it will deal with the housing crises.
Olga Williams · spoken · 2002-06-27 · support
- She worked for Milton Gaines and translated for him when he went around to speak to the neighbors.
- Most of the neighbors do not want all low-income housing.
- She is in support of this project.
Pat Delgado · spoken · 2002-06-27 · support
- She lives on 23rd and Treat Avenue.
- She has worked with various organizations to improve the Mission District.
- She and her husband have thoroughly looked over the proposed plans and is in favor of the project. She has been dismayed at the negative campaigning against this project.
Curtis Hagfeldt · spoken · 2002-06-27 · support
Bank of America - He endorses this project as part of a solution to a big problem.
- The number one issue is housing. The Mission is a vital backbone to this City.
Al Markus · spoken · 2002-06-27 · support
- He has worked in construction for more than 10 years.
- There are many positive aspects to this project.
Milton Gaines · spoken · 2002-06-27 · support
Co-Project Sponsor - He concluded that residential housing would most benefit the City.
- He talked to various organizations and spoke to various neighbors regarding this project.
Preston Gaines · spoken · 2002-06-27 · support
- His father is not a fly-by-night developer.
- His father is a Mission District business owner who has worked at this site for more than 30 years.
- This is the most responsible alternative use for this location.
Luis Granados · spoken · 2002-06-27 · oppose
Mission Economic Development Corporation - He believes that the Negative Declaration is inappropriate.
- Previous projects, which have been previously approved on a case-by-case basis, are not stated in the document.
- It does not take into consideration the Planning Department's rezoning of the area.
Alice Barkley · spoken · 2002-06-27 · support
Project Sponsor - This environmental review document takes into consideration existing context, like live work, which has already been constructed.
- She urges the Commission to support the negative declaration.
Judy West · spoken · 2002-06-27 · support
- They spent over two years working on a rezoning effort for this neighborhood.
- There is an effort to put housing in this area.
- A ban on housing is not what people have in mind for this area.
Mark Boyer · spoken · 2002-06-27 · support
- He asks the Commission to look into the future and approve this project.
Thomas Shuen · spoken · 2002-06-27 · support
Project Sponsor - His wallpaper company has become obsolete.
- He brought great pride and revenue to the Mission District and to San Francisco.
- This project of 54 units will become a source of pride and value to the neighborhood that he has served and has served him for 33 years.
Jose Montoya · spoken · 2002-06-27 · support
- He lives near the project.
- He supports the project because it will have seven much needed affordable units.
Alice Barkley · spoken · 2002-06-27 · support
Representing Project Sponsor - There are three major questions regarding this project: 1) should this project be delayed until the community planning process is completed? 2) Should this project have 25% inclusionary housing? 3) Whether the conversion of this site from heavy commercial/light industrial to residential use is appropriate?
- This project is an appropriate site for housing.
Maria Leon · spoken · 2002-06-27 · support
- She lives on Harrison Street.
- She supports this project because it will improve the neighborhood.
Myrna Sanchez · spoken · 2002-06-27 · support
- She lives on 23rd Street.
- She has born in the neighborhood.
- The project will bring people from all income groups.
- She hopes that the Commission will approve this project.
Marjorie Baer · spoken · 2002-06-27 · support
- She lives on Harrison Street.
- She has a jewelry manufacturing business. She believes that this project will not have a negative affect on her business.
- San Francisco needs housing and this project provides housing.
Ken Fox · spoken · 2002-06-27 · support
- He gave a financial report related to the project.
Jeff Austin · spoken · 2002-06-27 · support
- He has born and raised in the Bay Area.
- He supports the project as it has been presented today.
J.P. Sttepani · spoken · 2002-06-27 · support
- He read a letter from a neighbor who supports the project.
2003-03-13 · 54 comments · 27 / 27
Curtis Hagfeldt · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
In support for the project.
Barbara Garret · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
Supports the project.
Curtis Eisenberger · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
In support of the project.
Carolyn Deevy · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
In support of the project.
Patricia Delgado · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
- The project will be a welcome addition to the neighborhood.
Elizabeth Shepard · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
Is in support of the project.
Maria Leon · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
- In support of the project.
Eric Arguello · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
The proposed project will enhance the neighborhood.
Timothy Lee · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
Personally knows the developers and he knows that they will build affordable housing for everyone.
John Casner · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
Supports the project.
Marjorie Baer · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
This project will expand the possibilities of owning a place for a lot of people. No one will be displaced by this project, and the City and the neighborhood has a lot to gain from it.
Sylvia Alvarez-Lynch · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
- Supports this project.
Al Markus · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
This project offers a lot of people the opportunity to own property in the City.
Judy West · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
Supports the project as proposed
Dwight Dolliver · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
Is in support of the project.
Eva Hom · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
Project will be a wonderful asset to the City of San Francisco.
Milton Gaines · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
We (have not been and) are not the greedy, money hungry, evil businessman, and neighbor for the past 34 years.
This project is not displacing anyone. This project is good for the Mission.
Doug MacNeil · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
Supports the project.
Jaime Guerrero · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
This project is reasonable for an empty site. It provides safety, beauty and housing.
Celma Hidalgo · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
It will be a good asset for my neighborhood.
Brett Gladstone · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
Supports the project.
Kate White · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
Will gladly welcome more residents to the neighborhood.
Alfredo Pedroza · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
Respectfully asked the Commission to approve this project.
Judy Berkowitz · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
Sincerely hopes that this Commission will approve this project.
John Wilson · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
This project will be a positive thing for the neighborhood.
Thomas Shuen · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
Respectfully asked the Commission to approve the project.
This project will bring jobs and an opportunity to many people to own property in the City.
Nick Pagoulatos · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
- Concerned about housing affordability in the Mission.
This is a critical site.
The importance here is that this is transitional land. And even though there has been a lot of work done (struggles, etc.) to finally get the 12% affordability ordinance for housing in general, the City can not stop there. We need to continue and try to find out how we can increase the number of affordable units, both through non-profit … - Concerned about housing affordability in the Mission.
This is a critical site.
The importance here is that this is transitional land. And even though there has been a lot of work done (struggles, etc.) to finally get the 12% affordability ordinance for housing in general, the City can not stop there. We need to continue and try to find out how we can increase the number of affordable units, both through non-profit development and of course through private market development.
Asked the Commission to look at this project very carefully and set a precedent that is fair to the community and the developers.show more Araceli Lara · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
Opposed to the project.
Joel Yodowitz · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
As all of you know, this project has a very long and public history.
The project sponsor has conducted extensive neighborhood outreach, including meeting with individuals and groups, focusing within 300 feet of the project.
There has been multiple neighborhood meetings with invitations forward in English and Spanish, interpreters were present at each of these meetings.
The Project Sponsor's efforts should be a m… As all of you know, this project has a very long and public history.
The project sponsor has conducted extensive neighborhood outreach, including meeting with individuals and groups, focusing within 300 feet of the project.
There has been multiple neighborhood meetings with invitations forward in English and Spanish, interpreters were present at each of these meetings.
The Project Sponsor's efforts should be a model for community outreach and planning.show more Andrew Keller · spoken · 2003-03-13 · support
Gave an overall description of the project.
Richard Marquez · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
Mission Agenda is adamantly opposed to this project.
Despite the Dot.com boom and bust, hundreds of working Latinos were displaced and/or evicted.
Despite the lost of PDR jobs, despite the desperation of family housing, this struggle continues.
Ada Chan · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
- Opposes the proposed project.
Geri Almanza · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
Asked the Commission to make the following modifications to the proposed project: 1) we need larger overall units (2 to 3 bedrooms); 2) need deeper affordability, 60% of median income does not met the needs of our community. We need more like 40% of median income; 3) we want to see that affordable units will remain affordable for the life span of the building.
Aurora Amazola · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
Respectfully asked the Commission to approve affordable housing for low-income, hard working people in the Mission District.
Sarai Y.R. · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
Opposed the proposed project unless they include more affordable housing.
Yolanda Ruiz · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
We need more affordable housing for families with children.
Francisca Lopez · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
I am here to support that this project include more affordable housing. My family has a very limited resources and I am a sick person.
Margarita Mendoza · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
The Planning Commission should be aware of the necessity of affordable housing that matches the needs of hard working people in the Mission.
Jackie Marenco · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
Oppose the project because the Mission District does not need more over priced one-room apartments. The Mission is very family oriented and needs more affordable 2 to 3 bedroom apartments.
Gloria Vasquez · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
Asked the Commission to work with the people of the Mission and do not approve the project.
Bill Murphy · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
This project does not fit in the neighborhood. It won't benefit anybody that lives there.
Eli Gualip · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
Opposed to the project.
Teresa Almaguer · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
Objected to this project because it does not fully address the very obvious need of affordable family housing.
Jay Bradshaw · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
Supports affordable housing for working class families.
David McGuire · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
Opposed the project.
Alicia Bustos Sandoval · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
Asked the Commission to not take away affordable housing for the people of the Mission.
Charlie Sciammas · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
Opposed the project.
Katie Drelich · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
Please help the people of the Mission District that have been suffering for so many years.
Christina Olague · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
This housing project is out of our reach. People of the neighborhood could never afford to purchase any of these units.
Chris Selig · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
Asked the Commission to look very seriously at what affordability means?
Asked for more family affordable units.
Antonio Diaz · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
This is an inappropriate site for housing.
Owen Taylor · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
Opposed to the proposed project because it is inappropriate and insensitive to construct extremely unaffordable housing in a neighborhood that is already in need for affordable housing.
Marcella Azucar · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
Opposed the project because it is a human right to have housing.
Many families had to leave the City because of the lack of affordable housing.
Sue Hestor · spoken · 2003-03-13 · oppose
These units are going to be marketed to people who work at the Bank of America, to doctors who work in the Bio-techno company around of it. We need some housing that is marketed to people who live in the Mission.
MOTION #
1: Approve as modified by Commissioner Feldstein